Pre-arranged Trading Plan
A pre-arranged trading plan, also known as a 10b5-1 plan, is a predetermined plan that allows insiders to trade company stock automatically according to preset criteria, providing an affirmative defense against insider trading accusations.
The Trader's Take
The Signal
Pre-arranged trading plans allow insiders to trade legally even when they might possess material non-public information. Trades under these plans are less discretionary and may be less informative than discretionary trades.
The Noise
Many insider sales occur via pre-arranged plans for tax or liquidity needs and don't indicate negative sentiment.
Actionable Insights
- 1Distinguish between discretionary trades and pre-arranged plan trades on Form 4 filings.
- 2Check the adoption date of plans—plans adopted during low stock prices may be more meaningful.
- 3Look for cooling-off periods after plan adoption to ensure they're truly pre-planned.
- 4Frequent plan modifications can raise red flags about potential abuse.
Regulatory Context & Context
Common Misconceptions
Pre-arranged plans aren't "get out of jail free" cards—they must be entered into in good faith.
Plans can be modified, but modifications reset cooling-off periods.
The SEC requires disclosure of plan adoptions in quarterly reports.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a pre-arranged trading plan?
A pre-arranged trading plan (10b5-1 plan) is a predetermined plan that allows insiders to trade company stock automatically according to preset criteria, providing legal protection against insider trading accusations.
Are trades under pre-arranged plans less significant?
Generally yes, because pre-arranged plan trades are non-discretionary and may be for routine purposes like tax planning or diversification, rather than indicating strong sentiment.